If you’re considering adding or replacing decking in your garden, one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is whether to choose composite decking or wood decking. While both materials can provide a stunning outdoor space, the cost is often the key deciding factor for many homeowners.

In this article, we’ll take a close look at the costs involved with both options and explore whether composite decking is truly worth the investment in the long run.

Table of Contents SHOW

1. Initial Costs of Composite vs. Wood Decking

When it comes to the initial outlay, composite decking tends to be the more expensive option. The higher cost is largely due to the manufacturing process, as composite decking is made from a blend of wood fibres and plastic. These materials are engineered to provide a highly durable product that resists weathering, rotting, and insect damage, but this craftsmanship comes at a price.

On the other hand, wood decking, particularly softwoods like pine or spruce, comes with a much lower price tag upfront. Timber decking is often seen as the budget-friendly option for those looking to save on initial costs. However, it’s important to note that hardwoods, such as cedar or oak, while still cheaper than composite, are priced higher than softwood alternatives due to their added strength and longevity.

2. Installation Costs

The cost of installing decking is another factor to consider. In terms of composite decking, many homeowners find it easier and quicker to install due to its uniformity and design features like hidden fasteners. This can reduce the amount of labour required, leading to potential savings on installation costs. The cleaner, nail-free finish of composite decking also enhances its aesthetic appeal, though the hidden fastening systems can add a slight premium to the overall cost.

In contrast, wood decking generally requires more manual labour during installation. Wood boards are often installed using traditional nails or screws, which may take more time and expertise, especially when ensuring an even and secure fit. The additional labour required can increase installation costs, which might offset the initial savings on materials.

3. Long-term Maintenance Costs

When assessing costs over the lifetime of the decking, composite decking clearly comes out ahead. One of its major advantages is the minimal maintenance required to keep it in good condition. Composite decking boards do not need staining, sealing, or regular treatments to prevent rot or insect damage. A simple clean with soap and water a few times a year is usually enough to maintain their appearance, which significantly reduces ongoing expenses.

Wood decking, on the other hand, demands regular maintenance to retain its beauty and functionality. Homeowners can expect to stain or seal their timber deck every 1-2 years to protect it from moisture, UV rays, and wear and tear. If left untreated, wood decking can suffer from warping, cracking, and even rotting. These regular maintenance tasks not only require time and effort but can also add to the cumulative cost over time with the purchase of paints, sealants, and wood preservatives.

4. Durability and Replacement Costs

In terms of durability, composite decking is designed to withstand the test of time. Composite boards typically last anywhere from 20 to 30 years, with some high-end brands even offering warranties for longer periods. The durable nature of composite decking means it rarely needs replacing, which offers peace of mind for homeowners looking to make a long-term investment.

Conversely, wood decking, while initially more affordable, tends to have a shorter lifespan, typically around 10 to 15 years depending on the quality of the timber and the level of maintenance. In regions with wet or humid climates, wood decking can be more prone to damage from rot or insects, often requiring sections to be replaced or the entire deck redone. This means the long-term costs can rise substantially, especially if major repairs or replacements are needed down the line.

5. Environmental and Hidden Costs

From an environmental perspective, composite decking is often made using recycled materials, making it a more sustainable choice. The combination of recycled wood fibres and plastic reduces waste and provides a low-impact solution. Additionally, since composite decking doesn’t require regular painting, staining, or sealing, there are fewer harmful chemicals introduced into the environment.

Wood decking, while natural, comes with its own environmental costs. Although it is biodegradable and renewable, the demand for timber can contribute to deforestation if not sourced responsibly. Look for decking made from FSC-certified timber, which ensures the wood has been harvested sustainably. However, the use of wood preservatives, paints, and stains can introduce additional environmental and financial costs that shouldn’t be overlooked.

6. Value for Money and Resale Value

When evaluating the overall value for money, composite decking shines as a long-term investment. While the initial outlay is higher, the minimal maintenance costs, combined with its durability, mean that composite decking can save homeowners money in the long run. It’s also worth noting that composite decking can add value to your property due to its low-maintenance appeal, making it an attractive feature for potential buyers.

In contrast, wood decking may appeal to those looking for a more cost-effective short-term solution. However, the ongoing maintenance and potential replacement costs can quickly add up, and the lower durability of wood may mean that it doesn’t increase property value as much as its composite counterpart.

7. Comparing Aesthetic Value: Is the Look Worth the Price?

For many homeowners, the natural beauty of wood decking is a major selling point. The rich grain patterns and authentic texture of timber can create a warm, inviting outdoor space. However, maintaining this look requires consistent care, and wood can fade or deteriorate without proper upkeep.

While composite decking might lack the natural charm of real wood, modern composite boards are available in a wide variety of colours and finishes. Some composite decking even mimics the appearance of wood grain, offering a sleek, contemporary alternative. Though it may not fully replicate the feel of timber, the consistency in appearance and resistance to fading makes composite decking a visually appealing option for those seeking a modern, hassle-free outdoor solution.

8. The Cost of Composite Decking: Is Composite Decking Worth the Investment?

When comparing composite decking with wood decking, it’s clear that each material has its strengths. For homeowners who prioritise low maintenance, durability, and long-term value, composite decking is definitely worth the investment. The higher upfront cost is often offset by the savings on maintenance and the peace of mind that comes with a product that is built to last.

However, if you prefer the classic, natural look of timber and don’t mind the ongoing upkeep, wood decking could be a more budget-friendly option in the short term. Just be prepared for the long-term costs that come with regular maintenance and potential replacements.

Ultimately, the choice between composite and wood decking comes down to your personal preferences, budget, and how much time you’re willing to invest in maintaining your outdoor space.

If you’re ready to invest in high-quality decking for your outdoor space, browse our online store for a wide range of composite decking boards. Alternatively, if you’re looking for professional installation, our expert composite decking installers are here to help. Find out more about our installation service here.

Recommended reading: Composite Decking Calculator